“How much did you pay for that?” a woman asked, eyeing the badge-and-lanyard strung around my neck. I told her I was a critic, and that press accreditation for the Toronto International Film Festival was not for sale. She seemed unconvinced, and asked again with a conspiratorial twinkle, as if I were being coy about the price.
TIFF likes to call itself the “people’s festival”; however, a premiere can run $90 CAD, and considerably more once a ticket has landed on a resale site. The forms of access you can actually buy in bulk are designed for industry professionals, with credentials ranging from $590 to $1,250. Neither market badges nor the exchange of money is especially unusual behind the scenes of a film festival, though it is often much easier to ignore, if you’re buried in scheduling, in the romantic business of unearthing the next cinematic gem in a nearly 300-odd showcase.
Tuning things out was harder this year, as the industry kept intruding. The press footprint was visibly shrinking: The usual two press screenings per film became one, a telling shift that took on a more institutional shape with the arrival of the Market. Modeled on Cannes’s Marché du Film and Berlin’s European Film Market, TIFF: The Market fills the fall gap between them—Cannes in May, Berlin in February. Backed by $23 million in government funding, the Market, as per the official website, seeks to “bring together professionals from across film, series, and innovation to buy, sell, finance, pitch, and discover great content.” In other words, to formalize the transactions that typically take place in the plush confines of Nobu or the Ritz-Carlton.
The Market is housed at the Metro Toronto Convention Center, mere blocks shy of the festival strip. It is technically close, but far enough to be a nuisance, particularly for critics who file reviews cross-legged on the multiplex floor and measure distance in the minutes between screenings. Walking the patchy carpets of the windowless second floor, I felt I had clipped into an ill-fated, world’s-fair edition of The Backrooms. Empty booths and banners for various national cinemas ringed a Lavazza bar selling paper cups of espresso. Around the perimeter, a sparsely populated “food court” sold $25 CAD boxed lunches boasting “a taste of Asian, Indian, or Mediterranean cuisine.”
Absent were visible signs of commerce. There was little trace of the wheeling and dealing of agents and studio heads. Perhaps everyone was inside attending sessions like “Expanding IP: The Opportunity and the Risk” or “The Global Sales Playbook.” The market felt sealed off, with little engagement with the larger questions pressing on film culture: AI, the changing status of the image, and what it means to make and watch movies in an increasingly mediated world.
If the Market was TIFF envisioning the future of movies as business, the Innovation Hub was TIFF imagining it through technology. There is little allure for the average moviegoer in seeking out its inaugural selection of Virtual Reality projects—this was the destination one goes when vague curiosity (and an assignment) meets a window of free time, assuming one happened to have some time to spare. The most talked-about work by far was The Lesbian Simulator. In the 40-minute interactive game, Dutch artist Iris van der Meule sands down any whiff of the erotic embedded in its premise into a cuter fashion, as I experienced the highs and lows of sapphic life as a bright, blobby avatar and collected points in the form of carabiners. The docent told me North American audiences had been more receptive than the native Dutch ones, who apparently took offense at this teen-friendly piece.
Elsewhere, The Big Picture: Lunch Atop a Skyscraper turned the famous 1932 photograph of construction workers eating lunch above Manhattan into an interactive history lesson. Seated at a virtual desk, I picked apart the photograph’s origins and context. My brief VR encounter did little to persuade me of its artistic possibilities. The emphasis was pedagogical rather than aesthetic. These experiences don’t necessarily prize the image, and certainly don’t depend on it, which is why they feel so removed from cinema and hew spiritually closer to videogames.
All of this is just the apparatus surrounding the festival. But then there is the question of navigating it. Aside from Wavelengths and Midnight Madness, whose identities are at least legible (avant-garde cinema and late-night horror respectively), TIFF’s programming sections can feel like random taxonomy. Gala Presentations boast “red carpets and major audience interest.” Special Presentations offer “high-profile premieres and the world’s leading filmmakers.” Discovery is for “directors to watch,” presumably for those not yet worth watching, while Platform is “director’s cinema now,” raising the question of whose cinema it was prior, and what will happen come Tuesday. None of these describes what the films might encompass but how excited you’re meant to be about them.
The wiser, safer choice is to pay attention to the individual programmer (TIFF has a dozen), or, in this unfulfilling year, catch up with carryovers from Cannes, Berlin, and Venice—known quantities of a certain critical grade. Indeed, this is what I did. Having been burned before, I left the thrill of discovery to those with less to lose, having already completed the European festival rounds.
***
I found sustained, reliable pleasures in new films from old auteurs, beginning with Mike Leigh’s Tender Loving Care, a humane examination of Iife under the welfare state of the United Kingdom. Leigh’s swansong could be the alternate title for Ryusuke Hamaguchi’s latest, All of a Sudden, a nearly three-hour drama that trickles down like a long, cool drink of water from a pristine stream. Inspired by the correspondence between a Japanese philosopher and medical anthropologist, Hamaguchi recasts the exchange as the story of a French director of a long-term-care facility (Virginie Efira) and a Japanese director of experimental theater (Tao Okamoto). Set within the facility’s bureaucratic confines, the conversation-heavy film, dotted with the usual Hamaguchi trademarks of mirroring, performance, and chance, takes up the question of how to live in an increasingly fractured world, somehow making such an inquiry feel urgent rather than portentous. Even at 196 minutes, there is nary a dull moment, so I did not, could not, break for the washroom, as they call it in Toronto.
Possible Love, Lee Chang-dong’s long-awaited follow-up to Burning (2018), also centers on a spontaneous friendship between women, though here intimacy is occluded by ulterior motives and stratospheric class difference. Mi-ok (Jeon Do-yeon) is married to a laid-off factory worker; Ye-ji (Cho Yeo-jeong), a billionaire’s wife, is a documentarian hoping to film the couple. Where Burning left just enough room for creeping uncertainty, Possible Love, in its novelistic examination of these two couples’ lives and relationships, is more declarative (opening with one of the Ten Commandments, “Thou shalt not covet”). Parasite will inevitably be invoked, but the comparison flattens Lee’s interest in the private desires, unspoken resentments, and human contradictions of its characters. Under his watchful gaze, revelations arrive gradually through the most mundane details (calling a driver, picking up a birthday cake), ushering in a fresh set of tensions that alter the emotional balance of what came before.
Not everyone was moved by Possible Love’s finely tuned emotionality. I was told now and then a scoff flickered through the press screening. Against the customary silence of these screenings, havens of professional composure, the ecstatic real-time response to The Debut, Jesse Eisenberg’s gleefully absurd tale of community theater, felt like an anomaly. Word had apparently spread from Telluride, where the film premiered, that Julianne Moore’s bravura monologue earned a raucous round of applause mid-movie, and some in the audience were determined not to miss their cue. The clapping began before Moore finished, fell silent, then started up again in what amounted to an uneven chorus of approval for a scene still very much in progress. The actual end of the film was followed by an extended standing ovation, the sort of thing I associated with the performative audiences of Cannes.
But once, at least, we got it right. The crowd collectively gasped twenty minutes into Everytime, which features the festival’s most audacious and exquisite image, one that can’t be properly described without spoiling the event it depicts.
Sandra Wollner’s third feature wrenches a tale of grief away from tear-spattered processing toward something spectral and surreal, when a deceased girl’s mother, younger sister, and boyfriend travel to Tenerife for an oceanside escape. The resulting film is an ambient reverie that may superficially recall Aftersun (2022)—the films share cinematographer Gregory Oke—but where that film was an act of recollection, an exorcism of memory, Wollner’s is a knottier construction that folds digital traces of the dead (shots of iPhone messages, pixelated Facebook photos) into the larger, unstable landscape of bereavement and resourcefully draws on, of all things, open-world video games like Minecraft and Vintage Story. Wollner dedicates ample screen time to these games, played by the sisters, that concern survival and endless creation. The family’s vacation mirrors this arc, coping slides into something more frictionless, as the volcanic rock of the Canary Islands and the poolside resort become as otherworldly as the game’s procedurally generated terrain.
Marine Atlan’s debut, La Gradiva, also tempts us with a contemplative European vacation, this time to the coast of Naples with a group of high schoolers. Atlan works within the familiar armature of the coming-of-age story—loosely orbiting a half-Italian slacker and a frumpy, moody nerd—painting characters through extended conversations about politics and sex, flirtations and frictions that arise and recede. The narrative seems to take its cues from the place: the heat, the streets, the ruins, the long stretches of unstructured time.
Calling The Dreamed Adventure a crime thriller is almost unfair, a distinction likely to confuse those anticipating lawless bloodshed. That’s not to say personal or political violence is absent from the story of Veska (Yana Radeva), a female archaeologist who becomes entangled with a Bulgarian gang. Director Valeska Grisbech agitates the genre, making space for digressive asides in backyard gatherings and striking prosaic and feminine images: petrol smuggled while wearing heels, a bra strap slipping off an aging body, a box of tomatoes. While the Venice Film Festival just came under fire for its lopsided slate—one film directed by a woman—Toronto provided counterevidence with these perambulatory films. They let their plots go slack, ceding to place and to time spent, on the surface, doing very little, which stood out at a festival built around efficiency.
I left the theater in no hurry to do anything at all, still basking in the drift, only to find myself hustling into the queue for Club Kid, one of the festival’s more anticipated titles. Jordan Firstman’s ode to New York gay life, with its barbs at Balthazar, passed without much notice. First and foremost, it is a showcase for the writer-director-star, whose neurotic, self-lacerating charm is given plenty of room to roam, as well as a timely portrait of the city—its bars, apartments, and familiar corners. Fixating on these minor details was a welcome distraction from the anodyne, corporatized stretch of King Street (long lines for the Shin Ramyun booth) and from the film’s boilerplate and strangely moralizing tale of arrested development. A dedicated partygoer discovers he has a ten-year-old son and must grow up, fast, a process that entails becoming a sober bartender at Bar Oliver. The film proposes a mutual exclusivity between nightlife and parenthood—a proposition that would strike some real-life New Yorkers as needlessly punitive.
While Club Kid treats the past as something to outgrow, Alexandra Pechman’s Magazine, set in 2011 Manhattan, keeps it under glass. A shock of recognition, followed by a warm wave of nostalgia, pulsed through my body as I watched Nora (Lily McInerney), a college graduate acclimating to her big-girl internship, dressed in Peter Pan collars and ditsy floral dresses overlaid with a cheap boyfriend blazer. Nora is starting her summer gig at the prestigious fictional literary magazine Platen, seemingly modeled after The Paris Review, where status runs high but the office interiors remain humbly DIY. (The interns carry out their fact-checking perched on mismatched couches.)
Nora is from Arizona and insists she isn’t from money, but the film gives us little reason to believe her. Nor does it offer much evidence of her supposed poetic ambitions. She seems more interested in running her fingers over the candy-colored spines of the magazine’s issues (an empty recurring image) or sleeping with her older, divinely freckled, fully-employed coworker (Joshuah Melnick). Set pre-#MeToo, Magazine squanders an obvious opportunity to examine the power dynamics of this ecosystem: It never arrives at an observation as incisive as its wardrobe. No amount of Tumblr-era set dressing and highly-specific indie rock jams could save this limp script that hobbles from one montage to the next (there are so many).
At the other end of the publishing world sits Ink, Danny Boyle’s Rupert Murdoch biopic, which at one point uses generative AI to reanimate Margaret Thatcher. Just as Boyle settled in for the Q&A, an audience member screeched, “Never do that shit again.” The conversation promptly ended. It was the most succinct criticism I’d heard all festival, and it raised a question that seeped into my viewing: What does it take to put a person on screen, and what’s left of them once you have?
***
Back at the Innovation Hub, during a rare gap in my schedule, I tried Body Proxy by donning a pair of Ray-Ban Meta glasses that recorded my onboarding for a fictional startup that hires humans to perform physical tasks that AI, lacking a corporeal form, cannot yet manage itself. As a list of timed assignments appeared on a TV screen, I froze, baffled by the randomness and legality of the requests (draw a sad bovine; shred a dollar bill), and suddenly felt like an eight-year-old singled out in gym class, unable to demonstrate even the most basic motor skills. At the end, a printed performance report concluded: “A high variance physical asset severely bottlenecked by narrative, emotional, and stationary hardware requirements,” a withering assessment that more or less describes a moviegoer, waiting and hoping to feel something.
Two documentaries proved more forgiving of human limitations. In the three-part, five-and-a-half-hour The Life of Jorge Luis Borges, filmmaker Mariano Llinás revisits the Argentine author’s haunts with a scholar in tow. Self-indulgent and self-deprecating, he neither uncovers any rare texts nor does he deliver anything close to an exhaustive account of the writer’s life. Clues lead to digressions, digressions to dead ends, and dead ends to more questions, until the impossibility of fully knowing a subject becomes the film’s organizing and enchanting principle.
Canadian filmmaker Matthew Rankin goes the other way. Rather than concede a portrait’s limits, he overloads it in Ladies and Gentlemen, Brian Mulroney, which examines the former Canadian prime minister, beginning with the 1976 Progressive Conservative leadership convention that launched his ascent. A collage of archival footage and original animation (floating heads, flying convertibles, vintage primetime graphics), it is a feat of sheer visual showmanship, a fittingly maximalist portrait of a politician who understood spectacle himself. It is also, somehow, educational, the way a Canadian political-history documentary might be if watched on mushrooms.
Whether these films find a distributor is another matter. Last year, Obsession premiered to middling reviews, only for Focus Features to buy it for $15 million and watch it become a hit. The logic of criticism and the logic of the business don’t always run in parallel, a divide brought into sharp relief with my final film of the festival, Werner Herzog’s refreshingly bizarre Bucking Fastard. Rooney and Kate Mara play sisters who dress like tradwives and speak in eerie unison, as if marooned in an earlier century, though the film takes place in the present. The film refuses to explain their peculiar symbiosis and codependency, like why it takes two of them to pry open a tin of sardines.
As the credits rolled, I spotted a gaggle of YouTubers ahead of me trading takes in front of the camera. I couldn’t tell whether they had press badges or had bought tickets, and by then it seemed beside the point. A few blocks away, the Market’s booths sat empty. Nobody had bought Herzog’s film. The business may not yet know what to make of it, but the audience, at least, had begun to try.




