Girl on Girl: Does a Woman’s Sexual Experience Inform Her Identity?

•

I totally hear what you’re saying and respect it completely. I think we come at the word whore—and sexuality, perhaps—from two very different upbringings and experiences and I believe there is room for both your reaction and mine (and so many others!) in this conversation.

I will never know what it was like to be raised Mormon or even religious (I grew up with zero dogma as a secular Jew who celebrated Christmas and was very into crystals) but I do know what it was like to be the horny girl. And because my sexuality has always been a way I identify, I disagree that a woman’s sexuality is peripheral to her character. I have fought against the prudishness of our culture since I was old enough to realize how much it informed my own shame as a teenage girl. As an adult, sex still informs my work, character, and identity as much as anything.

Where it starts to make me uncomfortable is when you suggest that a woman should not feel elevated by her sexual power, insinuating that a woman’s sexual experience is neutral. There’s more church than you realize behind those words, flattening sexuality into something that doesn’t matter as much as I believe it does. A woman who feels sexually free is very different than a woman who has never explored that part of herself, who was robbed by shame of her own eroticism.

A woman’s sexuality is deeply personal, primal, and holier than any book, and therefore should be exalted as something for her to explore. A woman who owns her sexuality owns herself and, for many of us, how we understand ourselves sexually is intertwined with our identity as artists. That is why these churches try to shame women away from our bodies, handing them over to men with one hand while covering our mouths with the other. And the fact that female sexuality is so feared—by both men and women—proves my point.

The day you published your last column, my eighteen-year-old daughter—who comes with her own set of feelings and experiences re: the word whore—came home from school and announced that she was going to perform the Shane Gillis SNL cold open as her monologue for senior showcase. Her reaction to that shit was: Look at this fucking loser. How fun, now I get to make fun of him on stage, lol.

I took a very similar approach at her age as a young writer and never really stopped. I believe every woman should be responsible for how she defines her own power and if that means embracing the word whore, or even using it as a term of endearment or pride, more power to her. There is nothing shameful about sex work or empowerment through sexuality and, as long as women are criticized for their “body count” and praised for having limited sexual experience, I will keep pushing against that imbalance.

Also, I want to say I am grateful for the way you reacted to some asshole’s stupidity on a late-night comedy show. You took the rage it inspired, built a blowtorch out of words, then turned that fire toward the Mormon church. And at the risk of sexualizing that, IT TURNED ME WAY THE FUCK ON. Because to me, there is nothing hotter than a woman who knows where to put her anger. There is nothing more galvanizing than a woman who takes back her energy from god-sick fools and reinvests it in her own rebuilding. There is nothing that makes me prouder of a woman than her refusal to back down to the men who believe it’s somehow holy to leer over her. Women who call bullshit on the men who hide behind Jesus in order to justify their twisted worldview that, for women, submission is holier than power.

This SNL bullshit pushed you deeper into your own story. You reacted to some dude’s bad joke with this surge of fearlessness. You started working on the story you aren’t supposed to tell because it goes against everything you were taught not to say.

That is why I feel so hopeful about this moment. I am watching what’s happening in you and me and my daughters: our refusal to diminish, to dim, or to quiet. I am noticing the lack of fear women suddenly have, even those who were raised marinating in it.

Part of me is grateful for the Shanes of the world. They keep us activated. They remind us why we can’t be complicit, why we need more women on stage (and behind the scenes). More women burning down the churches that try to replicate a woman’s life force with the botched teachings of dead men. More women who unabashedly share their experiences and spend their lives unlearning in order to understand themselves and set each other free.

And, yes, I’m talking about you. In all your power, glory, rage, and brilliance, you.

Love,

Rebecca

SHARE

IG

FB

BSKY

TH

Click here to subscribe today and leave your comment, or log in if you’re already a paid subscriber.